Newsletter #216 - September 2011
Promoting the Vision of a Sustainable Vancouver Island
EcoNews Options
EcoNews PDFs
Subscribe to EcoNews
Get EcoNews by email each month:
* EcoNews protects the privacy of its email list, and does not share it with any other group or organization.
To receive EcoNews by mail, call Guy at (250) 924-1445.
EcoNews is a free monthly newsletter funded by your kind donations. It dreams of a world blessed by the harmony of nature, the pleasures of community, and the joys of personal fulfillment, guided and protected by our active citizenship.
AG00119_.gif (2913 bytes) If you value receiving EcoNews, could you send a donation to help cover the cost? There’s almost no money in the bank, right now. It costs over $1,000 a month to produce, and prices keep rising. For this we reach around 8,000 people, including every MLA in BC, and every municipal politician in the CRD.If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Donations can be sent to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, BC, V9E 2B9. EcoNews is not charity tax-deductible, but if you would like a receipt, please send a stamped self-addressed envelope. Donations can also be sent via PayPal:
The Money June July / Aug Sept
Copies printed 1500 1500 1500
Sent by email 3120 3130 3106
Print, postage $733 $339 $800
Editorial $450 $450 $450
Donations $660 $3072 You?
Advertising $75 $130  
Balance -$274 $2139 (Help!)
Many thanksto The First Unitarian Church of Victoria (congregational collection), The Pinch Group at Raymond James, Marian Kemp, R. Bilash, Janet Meadows, Helga Naguib, Christine Johnston, Doreen Hynd, Arnold Ranneris, Alison Fitzgerald, Pat Johnston, Chris Bullock, Hilda Dahl, Eleanor McKinnon, Richard Pearson, Marlene Rice, Roberta Hower, Andy Robertson, Nancy Turner, P. Buxcey, Gillian Smith, Ed Mackenzie, Dave Secco, Mignon & George Lundmark, Noel Taylor, Martin Weideman, Miriam Thorn, Andrew Pringle, Elizabeth Nuse, Anita Galitzine, Michael Collins, Janice Turner, Jean Rankin, Alison McLaren, Marian Kemp, Kathryn Harcourt, Marie Bohlen, Susan Grout, Brian Pinch, Peter Schofield, Mark Whitear, Barbara Hourston, Marya Nijland, Barbara Taylor, Penny Furnes, Peter Lamb, Jack & Heide Martin, Ruth Masters, Rich Mably, Sandra McPherson, Josephine Munro, Marta Gassler, Louise Irwin, Francis Kremler, Alan Dolan, Bob Willard, Frank Martens, Dennis Dolphin, Jean Wallace & Marjorie Vachell. Thankyou!

Saanich Organics Box Program

Certified organic veggies from our farms delivered directly to you.


Contact EcoNews

Guy Dauncey, Editor
13561 Barney Road, Ladysmith, BC
Tel (250) 924-1445

Executive director
The Solutions Project



Don't it always seem to go
That you don't kn
ow what you've got
‘Til it's gone
They logged paradise
And put up a housing lot.

We’ve got a huge land-use crisis on our hands on Vancouver Island, and an associated problem concerning the way we elect the people who make the decisions about the future of our Island.

At 32,000 square kilometres (3.1 million hectares), Vancouver Island is larger than self-governing nations such as Israel, Slovenia and Lebanon, and three quarters the size of Switzerland.

When it comes to governance, however, most of our Island has no municipal governance. Each non-incorporated area is represented by one Electoral Area Director, who is sometimes responsible for a vast area of land. Land-use decisions in these areas are made by these electoral area directors, or by their non-elected alternates.

As long as most of the Island was in active forestry, this was a manageable system. Now that forest companies are re-inventing themselves as real estate developers, however, seeking zoning decisions for new subdivisions, this primitive form of democracy is a huge problem, especially since regional directors sometimes vote on a mutual back-scratching basis.

The immediate crisis has arisen because in 2007 BC’s Forests Minister Rich Coleman lost leave of his senses, and allowed Western Forest Products (WFP) to remove 28,000 acres of forestland from its Tree Farm License, granting it a multi-million hand-out with no community consultation and no requirement for parkland protection.

WFP has now parceled the land up, and is putting 5,200 acres of waterfront land between Jordan River and Port Renfrew on the market on March 8th, under zoning rules that give minimal protection. The Land Conservancy is scrambling to save what it can, especially around the Sooke Potholes, Sandcut Beach, and the waterfront around Jordan River.

Others - including Mike Hicks, the Electoral Area Director, and Keith Martin, MP, are scrambling to get all levels of government together to buy the bulk of the WFP lands. There is a critical public meeting on the crisis at 7pm on Wed March 3rd at the SJ Willis Auditorium
, 923 Topaz Ave (250-370-9930 Ext 26).

Map of WFP LandsThe shaded area shows the extent of the
1883 E&N Rail Crown land grant

WFP is owned by Brookfield Asset Management, a conglomerate that also owns half of Island Timberlands, which owns 258,000 hectares of Vancouver Island, mostly in the Courtenay, Port Alberni, Nanaimo and Duncan regions. In 2009, another timber company, TimberWest, put 54,000 hectares on the market. For a map of WFP’s BC land holdings, see

It is our colonial history that has set us up for this. Back in 1884, Canada’s government gave Robert Dunsmuir, the coal baron and Nanaimo MLA, a contract to construct the Esquimalt and Nanaimo railway, plus $750,000, plus 2,000,000 acres covering the eastern half of the Island from Finlayson Arm to Seymour narrows (see map), plus the rights to all the coal and all the timber. The Dunsmuirs soon sold the land, making $11 million in 1910 dollars from the coal-mining rights alone.

That is all history, but it’s we who have to live with the consequences - we and the Coast Salish First Nations, who consider the E&N Rail grant “an egregious act of piracy” that is really upsetting their treaty negotiations.

The associated problem - how we are governed - is equally important, and right now is a critical time, since the BC government has just established a Local Government Elections Task Force to review specific issues relating to local government elections. We have until April 15th to send written comments - for the details, see You can also take part in the Think City - a Civic Electoral Reform Survey, on the same topic.

Right now, a real estate developer can donate as much as he or she wants to help sympathetic candidates get elected - and it happens all the time. A healthy local democracy might, among other things:

  • Require 100 local signatures for a candidate to stand (500 for Mayor);

  • Ban all corporate and union donations, as we do federally;

  • Limit individual campaign donations to $100;

  • Set spending limits for candidates;

  • Allow municipalities to adopt a single transferable or proportional voting system;

  • Reduce the voting age to 16 years;

  • Require all regional directors to vote on non-incorporated lands projects of more than 5 housing units, not just the electoral area directors.

A healthy non-corruptible democracy is our only hope of salvaging the mess left by the E&N land grant. Combined with proper zoning to govern the Island’s future land-use, based firmly on the principles of sustainability, all could yet be well.

- Guy Dauncey

The Eco-Personals

$1.00 a word. Max 5 lines; non-profits, low-income free. 1" box ad $50

Lovely room to rent, close to ocean, downtown, $30/night, 250-382-3810

For rent: New legal suite in "green" house. Centrally located. Loaded with features. 250-386-3886.

Wanted: The Green Party of Canada's Victoria organization is seeking board members with experience in event planning and/or fundraising. Please send your resumé to

Wanted: directors or volunteers to help the Vancouver Island Vegetarian Association (VIVA), dedicated to education, community events and potlucks.

Green votes for Margie Parikh in the Mountain Equipment Coop elections. Choose Margie! Please vote today at

Green Bites


Yea, 200th issue! But we’ll save the celebrations until October 2011, which will be EcoNews’ 20th birthday.  In the meantime, I need help in telling new people about EcoNews and giving copies to eco-minded friends. If you’d like 5 copies, just ask. 881-1304.



In November, I was invited to give a TEDx lecture in Vancouver, and chose this as my theme. The seven wonders that are possible, if we put our minds to it, are: (1) a shift to 100% renewable energy; (2) the greening of the economy so that all market decisions reflect Nature’s needs; (3) the end of warfare; (4) the end of poverty; (5) the end of cruelty to animals; (6) the establishment of democratic global governance; (7) the emergence of a globally unified spirituality. To watch the short 15’ video, see


Chris Edwards
Painter at your service - since 1989
Environmentally friendly paints
Residential & commercial, interiors, small exteriors. Free estimates.



Way to go! As a result of persistent campaigning by the Sierra Club of BC, Wildsight and the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society, and by your letter-writing, the BC government has announced a ban on mining and oil and gas development in the amazing, Flathead River Valley, in the south-east corner of BC. This is a great first step towards permanent protection of the Flathead as a National Park and Wildlife Management Area. On Thur March 25th there’s Sierra Club evening in Victoria to celebrate, and learn what’s needed next. See Green Diary.



You know about Facebook and Twitter - now there’s Carrotmobbing! This is a new approach to activism whereby people vote on-line in a contest in which businesses pledge to a proportion of their revenue to going green. The winner gets “carrot-mobbed”, meaning we all descend on the business that day, harnessing our buying power to support green change.

UVic’s Commerce Sustainability Club has just run such a contest, and the winner is the family-run Belgian waffle-makers Wannawafel in Market Square (just off Johnson), whose owners Ranaat and Krista have pledged to invest 100% of their revenues on Friday March 12th in environmental improvements under the guidance of Smallfeet Inc ( So make that a date to enjoy their waffles, and help them go green! See



Seattle has declared 2010 The Year of Urban Agriculture, aiming to make locally-grown produce affordable and available to as many Settle residents as possible, while supporting local farmers. Seattle has always been a leader on this.

Their 65 P-Patch Community Gardens provide space for 2,000 urban gardeners, and the city’s Comprehensive Plan calls for a community garden for every 2,000 households living within urban villages.

In 2008, a Parks and Green Spaces Levy, supported by 59% of Seattle voters, included $2 million for new community gardens during 2009-2012, managed by the Department of Neighborhoods P-Patch Program.

As part of its Year of Urban Agriculture, Seattle will allow backyard farmers more flexibility in what they can grow and raise on urban property (including chickens and goats), and there’s a old new program to create ten urban farms inside Seattle city limits. Residents are already allowed to plant food in the grass boulevard strips in front of their homes.

For Victoria, Vancouver and other municipalities that want to do more here, there’s food for thought here!



Before the white folks came along, rainfall dispersed naturally, filtered through the forests, fields and soil. When we built streets and houses, we channeled it away into pipes, and assumed we’d done a smart thing.

Not so, however, as now we’re realizing. The high velocity of the stormwater that comes out of the pipes has helped to destroy our once-abundant salmon streams; the contaminants from people dumping nasty substances down the drain and from road run-off (including toxic metals, oils, PCBs, solvents, pesticides, herbicides and leaded paint chips) have caused most of the region’s bountiful shellfish beds to be closed to harvest; and the toxic run-off is the chief source of PCB contamination in orca whales. That’s the price we pay for our old-fashioned 19th century system.
So what would sustainable stormwater look like? That’s what students and staff at UVic’s Environmental Law Centre (ELC) have been working on with their report Re-inventing Rainwater Management: Protecting Health and Restoring Nature in the Capital Region. (

Low Impact Development techniques aim to mimic the natural water cycle, restoring the function of trees, soil and open space, enabling the water to infiltrate down slowly through the soil to be released into the watershed. Such methods are also often cheaper. The ELC team has a raft of recommendations, including creating a CRD Rainwater Commission that would undertake an integrated watershed management approach. We have to think regionally for this.
If we do what’s needed, our children will be able to enjoy the magic of salmon in our urban streams, harvest local shellfish, and still wonder at the orca whales. ELC is hosting a public meeting on this at UVic on Thur March 4th, (see Green Diary) to get things happening. To learn about all their other great work, see



The Transition Towns movement is getting a hold in Victoria, with working groups set up to explore ways in which the Victoria region can increase our community self-reliance, and to craft an organized transition out of fossil fuels.

For those who are new to this, there’s a public meeting on March 18th (see Green Diary). For wider information about their meetings, see  and



The saga continues. Of the $2.5 million asking price to save Madrona Farm, just $250,000 remains to be raised - but by March 15th! So please, if you can contribute, please do so. See +


Seeds of Victoria
Locally grown - Open-pollinated
Certified Organic (IOPA 1406)
At all Dig This stores & online



Fair Trade, whereby the producers in the developing world receive a fair price for their food or crafts and invest some of the proceeds in community schools and local development - has a far higher profile in the UK than it does in Canada. They have just finished Fair Trade Fortnight - The Big Swap”, when people all over Britain were encouraged to switch to fair trade coffee, tea, chocolate, nuts, sugar, cotton and cosmetics.

Britain’s annual Fair Trade sales grew by 12% to £799 million in 2009, even in the depth of the recession, and many major retail players are actively selling Fair Trade products.
One fascinating result shows the value of fair trade in conflict zones such as Afghanistan, Palestine, Somalia and the Congo, where the justice-based economic model brings decent prices that can be used to improve living conditions and divert young men away from involvement in militias. Fair trade also builds trust-based structures such as cooperatives, which help restore social cohesiveness and stability in areas where fear, anger and corruption often dominate.
In Afghanistan, Britain is importing 70 tonnes of fair trade raisins a year from the Shomali Plains north of Kabul, where local traders have almost no trust of each other. The potential of fair trade as a way to build peace is enormous - the European market imports 600,000 tonnes of raisons a year, and many more could come from Afghanistan.
In Palestine, the profits from fair trade certified olive oil have funded scholarships for farmers’ children and supported the development of women’s’ cooperatives which produce other fair trade goods - all in the face of huge difficulties caused by the Israeli trade blockade and closed borders. Just think how much more could happen without the blockade, which has killed off the fair trade in crafts from Atfaluna, a deaf people’s charity in Gaza.
It just goes to show: there are so many ways to make this world a better place, and we need not despair until we have exhausted them all.



Farmed SalmonAlexandra Morton has been urging the government for years to get farmed salmon out of the wild salmon’s waters, because of the harm that the sea-lice on the farmed salmon cause to wild salmon as they migrate past the fish farms. 

90% of BC’s fish farms are owned by Norwegian companies, and Norway’s former Attorney General, Georg Fredrik Rieber-Mohn, has just written an urgent warning to BC based on Norway’s failure to protect their wild salmon from the very same threat.

Norwegian scientists have found nearly 100 cases of sea-lice that are immune to chemical treatments, and as a result, there are calls in Norway for drastic cutbacks to salmon farming.

We urgently need to heed his warning before it is too late for us here in BC. For action, go to and There is also a film and panel discussion on Farmed Salmon Exposed meeting at the Unitarian Church on West Saanich Rd. on Friday March 19th (see Diary).

Actions of the Month


Grizzly bearsMore than 11,000 grizzlies have been killed across BC since 1975 - and most by trophy hunters, for the joy of the kill. The hunting season starts again in April, and now, surely, is the time to end it. People all over the world want it to end.


Write to the Premier and to Barry Penner, Minister of Environment, urging them to stop this annual tragedy.



Polar bearOn March 13-15th, the global summit on Endangered Species (CITES) takes place in Qatar, and the US wants to prevent polar bear body parts from being sold internationally, which would remove much of the reason for killing these wonderful creatures, without impacting the Inuit’s subsistence hunt.

Canada’s Environment Minister Jim Prentice has said that he intends to oppose this, even though the polar bears are so threatened by the melting Arctic.


  • Write Rt Hon. Stephen Harper, PM, House of Commons, Ottawa K1A 0A6  pm@pm.gc.c

  • and to Hon. Jim Prentice, Minister of Environment (same address) 613-992-4275
The Wonderful World of Web
Submissions to EcoNews

To buy ad space in the next EcoNews, or to submit your event to next month's Green Diary, please contact:

Guy Dauncey, Editor
395 Conway Road, Victoria, BC
Tel (250) 881-1304

Deadline for April issue March 24th


NewspaperPlease feel encouraged to repost.

EcoNews provides this electronic version of the newsletter without charge even though it costs around $1,100 CDN to produce each month.

If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Please send it to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, B.C. V9E 2B9, Canada. Thanks ! (Not tax-deductible; if you want a receipt, please send a stamped addressed envelope).

Donations can also be sent via PayPal: