Newsletter #216 - September 2011
Promoting the Vision of a Sustainable Vancouver Island
EcoNews Options
EcoNews PDFs
Subscribe to EcoNews
Get EcoNews by email each month:
* EcoNews protects the privacy of its email list, and does not share it with any other group or organization.
To receive EcoNews by mail, call Guy at (250) 924-1445.
EcoNews is a free monthly newsletter funded by your kind donations. It dreams of a world blessed by the harmony of nature, the pleasures of community, and the joys of personal fulfillment, guided and protected by our active citizenship.
AG00119_.gif (2913 bytes) If you value receiving EcoNews, could you send a donation to help cover the cost? There’s almost no money in the bank, right now. It costs over $1,000 a month to produce, and prices keep rising. For this we reach around 8,000 people, including every MLA in BC, and every municipal politician in the CRD.If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Donations can be sent to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, BC, V9E 2B9. EcoNews is not charity tax-deductible, but if you would like a receipt, please send a stamped self-addressed envelope. Donations can also be sent via PayPal:
The Money June July / Aug Sept
Copies printed 1500 1500 1500
Sent by email 3120 3130 3106
Print, postage $733 $339 $800
Editorial $450 $450 $450
Donations $660 $3072 You?
Advertising $75 $130  
Balance -$274 $2139 (Help!)
Many thanksto The First Unitarian Church of Victoria (congregational collection), The Pinch Group at Raymond James, Marian Kemp, R. Bilash, Janet Meadows, Helga Naguib, Christine Johnston, Doreen Hynd, Arnold Ranneris, Alison Fitzgerald, Pat Johnston, Chris Bullock, Hilda Dahl, Eleanor McKinnon, Richard Pearson, Marlene Rice, Roberta Hower, Andy Robertson, Nancy Turner, P. Buxcey, Gillian Smith, Ed Mackenzie, Dave Secco, Mignon & George Lundmark, Noel Taylor, Martin Weideman, Miriam Thorn, Andrew Pringle, Elizabeth Nuse, Anita Galitzine, Michael Collins, Janice Turner, Jean Rankin, Alison McLaren, Marian Kemp, Kathryn Harcourt, Marie Bohlen, Susan Grout, Brian Pinch, Peter Schofield, Mark Whitear, Barbara Hourston, Marya Nijland, Barbara Taylor, Penny Furnes, Peter Lamb, Jack & Heide Martin, Ruth Masters, Rich Mably, Sandra McPherson, Josephine Munro, Marta Gassler, Louise Irwin, Francis Kremler, Alan Dolan, Bob Willard, Frank Martens, Dennis Dolphin, Jean Wallace & Marjorie Vachell. Thankyou!

Saanich Organics Box Program

Certified organic veggies from our farms delivered directly to you.


Contact EcoNews

Guy Dauncey, Editor
13561 Barney Road, Ladysmith, BC
Tel (250) 924-1445

Executive director
The Solutions Project



The wild salmon have been living in BC’s waters for 8,000 years, providing sustenance for the First Nations, and more recently for BC’s new settlers, who found such an abundance of salmon that they talked of being able to walk on the ocean on the backs of the salmon.

Since the new settlers arrived this abundance has seen a terrible decline, due to mixture of overfishing, migratory rivers being blocked by dams, river habitats being destroyed by logging, agricultural pollution, and fish farms.

In 2004, the Fraser River sockeye run collapsed.  In 2005, researchers from the Raincoast Conservation Foundation found that 75% of the salmon runs in northern BC streams were depressed.

In 2008, the Fraser sockeye returns collapsed again. The same year, the Sacramento River, so few chinook returned that the US federal government declared a fisheries disaster.

In 2009, California cancelled the entire coastal salmon season. A study found that only 10% of the chinook were wild salmon - the rest had been raised in hatcheries. In the Sacramento River, where once there had been 800,000, only 6,000 wild salmon returned.

In BC, in 2009, the north coast chum salmon returns collapsed - the main species the grizzly bears depend on. On the Fraser, instead of 10.5 million forecast sockeye, only one million returned. Is the ominous silence of the east coast’s cod fishery, which collapsed and has never returned, soon to be heard on the west coast?

Everyone wants to blame someone else, but on one factor, the science seems to be clear:
 “Salmon are thriving in Alaska where there are no salmon farms. They’re thriving in the western Pacific where there’s no salmon farms. But everywhere in the world these Norwegian salmon farms exist, wild salmon are going extinct - Norway, Scotland, Ireland, eastern Canada. The only people who’re denying it are government, and industry.”- Alexandra Morton.

Salmon farms throw such a wrench into the biological stability of the species that they are threatening its existence. (I am using material from Alexandra Morton’s website,

Salmon are SacredThe science shows that when you hold large schools of farmed salmon stationary in the ocean, it breaks the biological balance, enabling local diseases and parasites to infect wild fish at levels they cannot survive.

In the wild, when a fish gets sick, it begins to slow down and swim at the edge of the school, where predators remove it, causing disease epidemics in the wild to be extremely rare.

When farmed fish get infected with sea lice and diseases, however, the pathogens breed and reproduce at exponential rates with no predation.

When large numbers of farmed fish start dying, the companies use drugs to try to keep some alive, to get them to market. BC’s enhancement hatcheries must kill their sick fish to prevent the spread of disease; the fish farms face no such requirement.

In 2002-2003 the BC government allowed Norwegian fish farmers to hold 12 million IHN virus infected fish on BC’s largest wild salmon and herring migration on the inside passage of Vancouver Island. The 2005 Fraser River sockeye, which collapsed, swam through that epidemic as they went to sea.

The steelhead are in decline wherever they migrate through fish farms. The chinook salmon in Clayoquot are collapsing despite excellent river conditions. The Broughton pink salmon collapsed until fish farms started reducing their sea lice. The wild salmon and sea trout in Scotland, Ireland and Norway went into steep decline as the salmon farms in the lochs and fjords got larger.

So now, the big action. Alexandra Morton is walking from Sointula Island to Victoria in the Get Out Migration - a call to action to make the federal government in Ottawa aware that we want wild salmon to take higher priority than farm salmon.  Farms belong on the land, not in the ocean.

Hundreds are joining her, with salmon flags, placards and artwork.  “Unless we all stand up, our fish will continue dying of politics that no longer serve the people, nor our living world.”

On Wed May 5th, they’re on Gabriola.

On Thur 6th they’re walking to Duncan, with a 5pm evening event at City Square.

On Fri 7th, they’re walking from Duncan to Mill Bay for the 4:10 ferry, and a big presentation at 7pm at the Mary Winspear Centre in Sidney.

On Sat 8th they’re walking from Sidney to Victoria’s Centennial Square at 3pm, then on to the Legislature for the grand finale, with MP Fin Donnelly, the west coast Fisheries Critic. 

Alexandra is urging you to join her, to show the federal government that we want action to remove the fish farms from the ocean waters. For the details, see

- Guy Dauncey

The Eco-Personals

$1.00 a word. Max 5 lines; non-profits, low-income free. 1" box ad $50

Lovely room to rent, close to ocean, downtown, $30/night, 250-382-3810.

Trade land for food: Fully fenced chemical-free veggie garden, 30’ x 60' with well-fed drip-irrigation in Saanich. Call Susanne 250-744-2244.

New farm store at Suntrio Organic Farm, 8214 East Saanich Road (just north f Sanichton, across from Christmas Tree farm). Veggies, sprouts, fruit and other local products. May 7 to Nov, 9am-8pm every day.

To receive EcoNews by email go to and send an email to quit the paper list to

Green Bites


  • Oil escaping from the Deepwater Horizon oil-well blowout in the Gulf of Mexico: 5,000 barrels a day.
  • Barrels of Exxon Valdez crude oil that polluted Alaska’s seas: 343,000.
  • Time in which it will leak as much oil as the Exxon Valdez: 2 months.
  • Time it took to contain the last big blowout in the Gulf in 1980: 10 months.
  • Depth of the blowout: 1500 metres
  • Area of ocean polluted by April 27th: 4600 square kilometres.


Denise Savoie, MP (Victoria) writes:
EcoNews says it’s ‘Serving the Vision of a Sustainable Vancouver Island’, but I think this newsletter and its readers can stand to be more immodest. Through your tremendous advocacy for the Federal NDP’s Climate Change Accountability Bill (Bill C-311), you’re helping transform the vision of a sustainable Canada into a reality. If the bill becomes law, it will commit the federal government to achieve a GHG emission target of 80% below 1990 by 2050. On behalf of our NDP team, I want to thank you for keeping pressure on Parliament to pass it.

You may be interested to know of other Parliamentary climate change initiatives. My Green Commuter Choice Bill (Bill C-466), which has been endorsed by the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, would make employer-provided benefits tax-free for transit, carpooling and bicycle commuting.

There are MPs from all parties who are concerned about climate change and interested in obtaining non-partisan information, and in my role as Assistant Deputy Speaker, I’m co-hosting the Climate Change Speakers Series with the Pembina Institute. Our first roundtable updated MPs on the latest scientific research; the next featured a rigorous dialogue with an expert on carbon pricing. I’ve been encouraged by how my colleagues have explored areas of consensus constructively. By holding the details of what we each say in confidence and respecting differences, members feel freer to share ideas and seek solutions. In this way, I hope we may serve our constituents with integrity, and serve your vision of sustainability with resolve.



City farmSol Kinnis writes:
When you buy produce from City Harvest, you buy veggies with very little carbon footprint - even less if you walk or bike to our weekly market. City Harvest grows really local food. For the past six months, the members of the Co-op - Alix, Sharon, Sol and Karen - have been tearing up sod, building soil and planting seeds as we convert 12 Victoria backyards into small scale working farms. You might see one of us towing our tools and bins, since we use bikes and trailers to get around. 

We use SPIN-Farming methods - sustainable intensive farming practices on small plots in rural or urban centers. The business was founded by Paula Sobie and Martin Scaia in 2007; as the new owners we are building a worker co-op structure that uses mutual aid to overcome the challenges of surviving as farmers. See and sign-up for our list.



If you like working outdoors, eating delicious food, and meeting new people, this year’s Conservation Holidays from The Land Conservancy include ecoforestry education at the Wildwood Ecoforest near Ladysmith (July) and shoreline clean-up at South Winchelsea Island (Sept).

You can also stay at the Sooke Potholes Campground and wake up to the sound of rushing water and the smell of Douglas fir and stovetop coffee. The campground, which opens May 21, contains 60 tent and RV sites and a bicycle camp, all just off the Galloping Goose. All proceeds support the TLC’s conservation work. Call 250-383-4627 or visit



Every time you wipe, you can either save or harm the forest. If you buy recycled toilet tissue, each kilogram will save 30 litres of water and 3-4 kilowatt hours of electricity, compared to virgin paper straight from the forest.

Greenpeace estimates that of the 7 billion toilet rolls used every year in America, only 2% are made from recycled fibres; when our bums insist on virgin paper, they put extra pressure on the forests, and all the creatures that live there.

If everyone in Canada switched to recycled paper, we could leave 48,000 trees standing every year. Ideally you want to use non-bleached, 100% post-consumer recycled paper. Ponder this, the next time you sit on the throne.



When I arrived in Victoria 20 years ago, the forests were under assault. After persistent campaigns by thousands of activists, some has been saved, but on most of Vancouver Island it’s logging as usual. Now a new organization has arisen, the Ancient Forests Alliance (AFA), led by the irrepressible Ken Wu who achieved so much when he was with the Western Canada Wilderness Committee. The AFA is working to build broad-based support among First Nations, businesses, faith groups, scientists, and naturalist clubs.

In the May 2010 The Victoria Naturalist, Ken quotes a 2001 report for the Ministry of Forests in which Dr. Peter Pearse described the history of high grade overcutting:

“The general pattern was to take the nearest, most accessible and most valuable timber first, gradually expanding up coastal valleys and mountainsides into more remote and lower quality timber, less valuable, and costlier to harvest. Today, loggers are approaching the end of the merchantable oldgrowth in many areas, and are caught in the vise of rising costs and declining harvest value. The primary sector of the industry no longer earns an adequate return.”
Today, 75% of the productive old-growth forests on Vancouver Island have been logged, including 90% of the valley bottoms where the biggest trees grow and most biodiversity resides.

The ASA has a petition at calling on the government to create a Provincial Old-Growth Strategy to inventory and protect the remaining oldgrowth forests in regions where they are scarce. They have an urgent goal to raise $20,000 by this summer, to build their campaigns. See



Ponder the Sun, and its power. Just 8 minutes and 19 seconds ago, the heat you are feeling was on the surface of the Sun - and it has been producing energy for over 4.5 billion years. May 29/30th sees BC’s first Solar Days, with activities around the province to highlight the role that solar energy can play in our lives.

In 2009, Europe’s Solar Days had 7,700 activities in 13 countries; now it has arrived in BC. In Saanich, on May 29th, there’s a Solar Open House at Saanich Commonwealth Place, Elk Lake Drive, where you can meet local solar installers. 

The $2,000 incentive for a solar hot water installation on your roof is still in place for a limited time. See



200 million years ago, when Sun poured its energy into Earth’s early forests, some of the trees fell into swamps, and were preserved. Slowly, the Sun’s energy was compressed, heated, and turned into coal. It was coal that provided the energy for the industrial revolution, and coal that prompted the settlement of Vancouver Island - but when we burn the coal, the released ancient carbon traps heat in the atmosphere. Coal is now the biggest cause of global warming, and its continued use must be stopped.

And yet, even while the government wants to reduce BC’s carbon emissions, four new coal mines are being proposed for BC:

As the Wilderness Committee puts it, coal is “BC’s dirty secret”. (See BC exports over 20 million tonnes of coal a year, mostly to Korea and Japan. Each tonne of coal burnt produces 2.8 tonnes of CO2, so BC’s exported coal produces 56 million tonnes of CO2 a year - that’s getting close to BC’s entire domestic emissions of 63 million tonnes a year.

Our exports of natural gas produce a further 53 million tonnes of CO2e. All this has to end; we must also find a way to make steel without coal.

On Monday May 10th, Ben West from the Wilderness Committee is speaking at the BC Sustainable Energy Association’s Victoria Chapter meeting at the Burnside Gorge Community Centre. Come and learn more!



Ever felt the cars are too fast, and it’s just not friendly for pedestrians? A “walking audit” is a planning tool that can help turn your neighbourhood into a livable place.

Dan Burden pioneered the idea in the early 1980s, when he learned that engineers often never walked the corridors they were designing.  A walking audit gets people together onto the street, and brings down the shields between neighbourhood advocates and technical staff.

Some graduate students in urban design say they can learn more in a two-hour walking audit than in an entire semester of urban design classes.

If you want to promote the idea of a local walking audit with your council’s planning staff, you can find all the how-to at



It’s a big $6.6 billion decision, and the BC government has just signaled that the long-planned Site C dam on the Peace River will go ahead, after a two year period of environmental assessment. On the one hand, this much new green power could help shift BC’s transport to electric power, and help towards the closing of coal-fired power plants Washington or Alberta, if it was exported.

On the other hand, it will flood 4,700 hectares of high quality farmland - enough to feed the whole of the Peace region with local produce, instead of shipping it in from far away in fossil-fueled trucks. It will also drown the rights of the West Moberly and Salteau First Nations, who have communities in the Valley, and disrupt the migration corridors of local wildlife.

Northeast BC also has huge wind energy resources - the BC Sustainable Energy Association has calculated that if the same $6.6 billion were invested in wind energy, it could produce from 46% to 267% more green power a year. Their conclusion is that the Site C dam merits a very thorough and transparent analysis before it is finally approved.

Action of the Month


What to do about climate change? The rapidly approaching emergency is as real as ever, but the global treaty-making process has come unstuck, and the deniers are having a field day.

The annual G-8 and G-20 Summits are intended for the leaders of the world’s largest nations to discuss their important concerns - such as addressing climate change, tackling global poverty, and creating a just global economy.

This year, Canada is hosting at the meetings in Huntsville, Ontario (June 25-27), but Harper is refusing to make climate change a priority, and has cancelled the normal pre-meeting of the world’s Environment Ministers. We have to let him know that this is just so unacceptable; many other world leaders are frustrated, and think the same way.


Phone, write, email Stephen Harper, expressing your views.

Rt Hon Stephen Harper, Office of the Prime Minister, 80 Wellington St, Ottawa K1A 0A2.  
Email:  Tel: 613-992-4211

See also At the Table 2010 - for the G8 and G-20 Summits

The Wonderful World of Web
Submissions to EcoNews

To buy ad space in the next EcoNews, or to submit your event to next month's Green Diary, please contact:

Guy Dauncey, Editor
395 Conway Road, Victoria, BC
Tel (250) 881-1304

Deadline for April issue March 24th


NewspaperPlease feel encouraged to repost.

EcoNews provides this electronic version of the newsletter without charge even though it costs around $1,100 CDN to produce each month.

If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Please send it to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, B.C. V9E 2B9, Canada. Thanks ! (Not tax-deductible; if you want a receipt, please send a stamped addressed envelope).

Donations can also be sent via PayPal: