Newsletter #216 - September 2011
Promoting the Vision of a Sustainable Vancouver Island
EcoNews Options
EcoNews PDFs
Subscribe to EcoNews
Get EcoNews by email each month:
* EcoNews protects the privacy of its email list, and does not share it with any other group or organization.
To receive EcoNews by mail, call Guy at (250) 924-1445.
EcoNews is a free monthly newsletter funded by your kind donations. It dreams of a world blessed by the harmony of nature, the pleasures of community, and the joys of personal fulfillment, guided and protected by our active citizenship.
AG00119_.gif (2913 bytes) If you value receiving EcoNews, could you send a donation to help cover the cost? There’s almost no money in the bank, right now. It costs over $1,000 a month to produce, and prices keep rising. For this we reach around 8,000 people, including every MLA in BC, and every municipal politician in the CRD.If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Donations can be sent to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, BC, V9E 2B9. EcoNews is not charity tax-deductible, but if you would like a receipt, please send a stamped self-addressed envelope. Donations can also be sent via PayPal:
The Money June July / Aug Sept
Copies printed 1500 1500 1500
Sent by email 3120 3130 3106
Print, postage $733 $339 $800
Editorial $450 $450 $450
Donations $660 $3072 You?
Advertising $75 $130  
Balance -$274 $2139 (Help!)
Many thanksto The First Unitarian Church of Victoria (congregational collection), The Pinch Group at Raymond James, Marian Kemp, R. Bilash, Janet Meadows, Helga Naguib, Christine Johnston, Doreen Hynd, Arnold Ranneris, Alison Fitzgerald, Pat Johnston, Chris Bullock, Hilda Dahl, Eleanor McKinnon, Richard Pearson, Marlene Rice, Roberta Hower, Andy Robertson, Nancy Turner, P. Buxcey, Gillian Smith, Ed Mackenzie, Dave Secco, Mignon & George Lundmark, Noel Taylor, Martin Weideman, Miriam Thorn, Andrew Pringle, Elizabeth Nuse, Anita Galitzine, Michael Collins, Janice Turner, Jean Rankin, Alison McLaren, Marian Kemp, Kathryn Harcourt, Marie Bohlen, Susan Grout, Brian Pinch, Peter Schofield, Mark Whitear, Barbara Hourston, Marya Nijland, Barbara Taylor, Penny Furnes, Peter Lamb, Jack & Heide Martin, Ruth Masters, Rich Mably, Sandra McPherson, Josephine Munro, Marta Gassler, Louise Irwin, Francis Kremler, Alan Dolan, Bob Willard, Frank Martens, Dennis Dolphin, Jean Wallace & Marjorie Vachell. Thankyou!

Saanich Organics Box Program

Certified organic veggies from our farms delivered directly to you.


Contact EcoNews

Guy Dauncey, Editor
13561 Barney Road, Ladysmith, BC
Tel (250) 924-1445

Executive director
The Solutions Project



In the Greater Victoria region of North Saanich, organic farmer Brian Hughes has a problem. In July, deer wandered onto his farm and ate 6,000 of his strawberry plants. Last week, they ate a 40 feet bed of organic lettuces. Other farmers and growers on the Island and the Gulf Islands are reporting similar problems.


The black-tailed deer have lived on Vancouver Island for thousands of years. A mature doe gives birth to two fawns a year, each May or June. As part of Vancouver Island’s ecosystem, they are preyed on by cougars and wolves. Over millions of years, they have co-evolved alongside their predators, like most of the world’s herbivores.

Without predators, deer can live for ten years or longer. Over ten years, a doe might produce 16 fawns, 8 of which are female.  After ten years, assuming no deaths from predators, hunters or car accidents, a doe’s family line will have 500 female offspring. In ten more years it will number 200,000 females (plus 200,000 males), and they all need to eat. It’s no wonder they are wandering all over Oak Bay, browsing on the roses.

It’s easy to see why this spells such trouble for our farmers and growers. On Sidney Spit, the entire forest undergrowth has been eaten away by predator-free deer. There is only one rational solution, but first let’s consider the bunnies.

At the University of Victoria, there are 1600 bunnies, the descendents of pet rabbits whose owners have tired of them and dumped them there.

Female bunnies produce three to five litters a year, and each litter has three to seven babies - that’s a total of 9 to 35 babies a year. The following year, the female bunnies all start breeding. Like the deer, rabbits co-evolved with their predators - that’s why they have so many babies. If they are sheltered from predators, hunters and disease, and have enough grass to feed on, after 5 years there will be 50,000 females. After 7 years there will be over ten million.

Wot - me? Too much sex?

It’s easy to see why this spells such trouble for UVic, even if disease and predation by hawks and eagles slow “the Australia problem”. Within ten years of the introduction of 12 bunnies into Australia by a settler in 1859, two million rabbits could be shot or trapped a year without any noticeable impact.

The ecological solution would be to re-introduce their natural predators by breeding cougars and wolves for local release. This might turn walking the dog into a whole new experience, and create interesting adventures for cats, but this is not something most people would welcome.

That leaves three solutions - to replace the role of the predators we have driven out by organizing an annual cull; to attempt to sterilize them all; or to protect them in wildlife sanctuaries. They are cute, and appeal to our instinct to protect - but how many million can local sanctuaries take? Shipping them to Texas makes no sense at all.

Sterilization may work for rabbits if we are willing to pay the cost; but how can we sterilize all the local wild deer?

This is the point at which ecological ignorance, the desire to protect and the desire to eat meat intersect.

What has meat got to do with it? Everything - for it is highly contradictory for anyone who eats meat to complain about killing rabbits and deer when their own eating requires the constant killing of lambs, cows, ducks, chickens, pigs, and other animals. And on the other hand, venison and rabbit offer a source of local meat that has at least enjoyed a wild life, not one in a ghastly factory farm.

Does anyone apart from a vegan who eats no animal products have a moral right to argue that there should not be a cull of the rabbits and deer?

And yet my personal reason for being a vegetarian is to reduce the deaths of animals, and when I look into those bambi or bunny eyes, my instinct too is to protect them.

So where do bacteria fit in? Bacteria also breed like rabbits, only much faster, which gives them great evolutionary flexibility. When we misuse antibiotics, we get multi-drug resistant bacteria such as MRSA. In August, an even more scary threat arose in India in the form of a gene that passes easily between bacteria and makes them resistant to almost all of the powerful, last-line group of antibiotics. To imagine a future without antibiotics, we just have to look back to the last century. It’s a very grim thought.

The common factor that links the bambies, bunnies and bacteria is ecological ignorance. We urgently need ecological education for all children in our schools. Our universities should make it a requirement of entry. We cannot act wisely or live in harmony with Nature if we are so ignorant, ecologically.

For the bunnies and bambies, and to protect our own need to grow more food, we are going to need to accept an annual cull, celebrating the lives of the deer with an annual venison feast. Then farmers like Brian Hughes will also be able to grow the organic food we need without fear of going bankrupt by feeding his crops to the deer.

- Guy Dauncey

The Eco-Personals

$1.00 a word. Max 5 lines; non-profits, low-income free. 1" box ad $50

Need a great looking website? Want help with branding? Modern Love Design Studio offers prompt, affordable, friendly service. No detail overlooked in making your organization stand out. Non-profit discount available. Contact

Lovely room to rent, close to ocean, downtown, $30/night, 250-382-3810.

Mature female pet/house sitter seeks room in Victoria for when not sitting, with use or share of stove, fridge, washer, dryer. Pay per day or barter when present. 250-383-5144  ext. 3007

To rent: cute cottage in North Saanich woods, large secluded forest acreage, shower, totally renovated, refinished wood floors, new septic, skylights.  $950 plus utl. Non-smoker, long term. Renate 250-858-6511

Follow @GuyDauncey on Twitter for links to important news stories.

Green Bites


What are other people thinking? It’s fascinating to peak inside their minds. This summer, the Pembina Institute commissioned a survey of 5,000 global thought leaders in Canada, US and Europe, and asked various questions relating to sustainability. 68% of the 4,300 Canadian thought leaders were government experts or professionals. 20% were academics, and 12% were from the private sector or non-profit world.
So what are these folks thinking? In the Canadian view, the top priorities for decision-makers are climate change (44%), renewable energy (42%) and water issues (25%). On key topics, this is how many of them rate Canada’s performance as poor or very poor:

   Efforts re sustainable energy: 84%
   Climate change: 77%
   Green economy: 75%
   Expanding renewable energy: 68%
   Protecting natural ecosystems: 51%
   Protecting fresh water: 50%
   Health impacts of pollution: 49%

Why is Canada doing such a poor job? 69% think it’s the absence of federal leadership. And the best clean energy solutions? The results are encouraging, especially how few think nuclear or clean coal are viable solutions:

   Increased energy efficiency: 60%
   Sustainable community design: 57%
   Education and communication: 55%
   Renewable energy: 55%
   Nuclear power: 17%
   Clean coal with carbon capture: 7%

It’s also good news that 79% think that Canada should have a carbon tax, either alone (27%) or combined with a cap and trade system (40%). Only 3% think neither is needed. On Alberta’s oil/tar sands, 50% think new developments should be suspended, scaled back, or halted permanently, but 46% think they are fine as they are or should be accelerated. 64% think that progress on creating a long-term management plan for the tar sands is poor or terrible.

It is encouraging that so many thought leaders in government think this way; if only we had a way to break the political log-jam in Ottawa, which results in our being governed by people who are so backward in their thinking, and don’t represent the way most Canadians think.

What can we do? Locally, we can shake things up by electing Elizabeth May as Canada’s first Green Party MP in the next federal election in Saanich-Gulf Islands. Both Britain and Australia now have Green Party MPs. Canada must be next! To volunteer to help, go to

Not black or brown!



If there’s one kind of energy we absolutely must stop, it’s coal - and this makes the proposal to start a new underground coal mine in the Comox Valley so wrong, immoral, and ecologically unethical. Burning coal is the #1 cause of global warming, which poses the most terrible threat to our children, our civilization and our planet. Mining and burning coal is like pouring oil into a burning house, instead of water - and our children are still inside the house.

The project is called the Raven Underground Coal Project, and it is planned inland from Buckley Bay, opposite Denman Island, in the Tsable Creek watershed. If allowed, it will produce 2.2 million tonnes of coal a year for 20 years, to be burnt in Asia.
The coal is metallurgical coal, used to make steel, but we can make steel without coal, using hydrogen or biogas; the only reason for the project is financial profit. As for jobs, there could be far more new jobs generated in the Comox Valley if the Chamber of Commerce helped develop a program to help would-be entrepreneurs with business start-ups and cooperatives. All that the coalmine will bring locally is pollution, noise, coal trucks, a few lung-threatening jobs, and guilt.
How can we stop it? It’s currently entering the federal environmental assessment process, where we can all have our say. We also need to persuade Premier Campbell to announce “No more coal mines in BC”, in keeping with the province’s commitment to a green economy. See and Action of the Month.



Globally, the transition to a green economy is accelerating. Hazel Henderson is a world famous green economist who has created The Green Transition Scoreboard, which tracks investments in the global green economy using a robust and consistent framework. An annual green investment of $1 trillion every year is needed to ramp up material and energy efficiencies, and reduce the cost of solar, wind, geothermal, water, sustainable land-use and forestry, totaling $10 trillion by 2020. To put this in perspective, this would be 10% of the total value of global pension funds and institutional portfolio assets.
So how are we doing? In December 2009, the green invested total was $1.24 trillion; by August it had risen to $1.65 trillion. That’s a 33% rise, which keeps us on track for $10 trillion of green investments by 2020.
How can you help? By increasing the share of your pension and other funds that are invested in the new green economy. In Victoria, you can get professional advice on how to green your investments from Frank Arnold, The Pinch Group at Raymond James (, 250-405-2420) and Stephen Whipp (250-405-3550 You can find a nation-wide list of green financial advisers here:

Agenda for a New Economy


On Thursday September 30th the visionary author and lecturer Dr. David Korten will be in Victoria speaking on his new book, Agenda for a New Economy: From Phantom Wealth to Real Wealth.

With the Wall Street economy showing the full extent of its disastrousness, David Korten is showing how we can reclaim the “Main Street” economy for real values, real goods, and real money. His talk is at Victoria City Hall at 5:30pm, hosted by the Cascadia Green Building Council. See and his blog at




Fresh peppers with mustard
Food locally food
Glazed apples with custard

The local food revolution is also speeding along, aided by numerous local champions. When the Moss Street Market was founded in 1992 it was the only one in the whole region.  Today, there are at least 16 street markets selling locally grown food in Greater Victoria, and more farms producing organic produce than ever before.

We’re still got a huge way to go, however, and much farmland seems to be growing hay for horses, rather than real food. Carolyn Herriot, author of best-selling book The Zero Mile Diet - a Year-Round Guide to Growing Organic Food, is proposing that 10% of all land zoned agricultural should be required to grow food.

South of the border, the newly formed Slow Money Alliance has set a goal that by 2020, a million Americans will be investing 1% of their assets in local food systems. We need the same here. See
More people are also growing their own food, learning skills that their grandparents took for granted. There are numerous courses and workshops to help us learn - see If you want to grow winter vegetables in your garden this fall, there are winter vegetable bedding plants available from Fiona Chambers at Metchosin Farm. See
For urban growers, LifeCycles has just launched the Urban Agriculture Hub, as an interactive community-driven website connecting local residents with each other and with the resources they need. It features Events, a Forum, a Resources page, a Directory, a Featured Garden, and a Materials List for gardening materials. See

There are three big food celebrations coming up on three successive Sundays - Feast of Fields in Metchosin on Sunday Sept 19th; Eat Here Now in Centennial Square on Sunday 26th; and The Chef’s Survival Challenge - the Quest of the Golden Broccoli at Madrona Farm on Blenkinsop Road on Sunday October 3rd. Many volunteers are needed for this epic event, so if you can help, email, and see
Finally, Madrona Farm has been protected forever, thanks to the generous donations of 3000 donors! It is now one of BC’s special places, owned by The Land Conservancy. The celebration will be part of the Chef’s Survival Challenge on October 3rd.


A Year-Round Guide
to Growing Organic Food
by Carolyn Herriot

In all good bookshops and online at

The Zero-Mile Diet



In April 2009, Ontario banned the cosmetic use of pesticides throughout the province. Since then, streams that were sampled in five areas have shown an 80% reduction in their pesticide loading. This is good news for all the streams, the wildlife, and the humans who will no longer be exposed to toxic chemicals for the sake of a few less dandelions.

Here in BC, the Liberal government is still sitting on its hands when it comes to action, even though 88% of the respondents to its public consultation called for such a ban. Enough with these toxics! To get involved, and take action, see



There’s good news from Ecuador, where a historic agreement has been reached to save the Yasuni National Park from exploration for oil. An International Trust Fund has been set up to compensate Ecuador for not exploiting its oil resources, but it needs pledges of $100 million over the next 18 months, to activate it, towards a total of $3.6 billion. So far, Germany has committed $50 million, but no-one else.
There’s also good news from Indonesia, which has placed a two-year moratorium on all new forest clearing, under a partnership in which Norway will invest $1 billion to reduce greenhouse gas emissions through forest destruction.
Globally, illegal logging in the world’s forests declined by 22% in the past decade, but it’s still a huge problem, with 100 million cubic metres of illegal timber being cut down every year, according to a new report from Britain’s Chatham House - enough to circle the world ten times with logs laid end to end. Illegal logging has fallen by 50% in Cameroon, 50-75% in the Brazilian Amazon, and 75% in Indonesia, but it still accounts for between 35-72% of logging in the Brazilian Amazon and 40-61% in Indonesia, which will presumably continue in spite of the new moratorium. China is the world’s top importer and re-exporter of illegal wood. In the US it is now illegal to handle illegally harvested timber, and this July, the European Parliament overwhelmingly approved a similar crackdown, voting 644-25 in favour. Does Canada have similar legislation? Not that I’ve heard of, and there are very dubious auctions of unlabelled imported timber that happen locally.
What can we do ourselves? When buying timber, aim to use recycled timber, or timber that has been certified by the Forest Stewardship Council. If you must buy exotic hardwoods, ask your local timber store where the wood comes from, and for evidence that it has not been imported from China.

Action of the Month


If we all push together, we can stop the planned coalmine in its tracks. There are three avenues open to us:

1. Write letters to your local paper - they do get noticed.

2. Write to Premier Campbell and BC Minister of Energy Bill Bennett, urging them to place a moratorium on all new coal-mining in BC until full carbon capture and sequestration has been adopted by the nations we export to.  Write to  and

3. File a comment in the federal environmental assessment process (deadline Sept 20th) asking:

   (a) That the Minister refer the environmental assessment of Compliance Coal Corporation’s proposed Raven Underground Coal Project to a joint federal/provincial independent expert Review Panel for full public hearings (CEAR reference 10-03-55529).

   (b) That before any consideration is given to the project, comprehensive aquifer mapping and modeling of the entire Raven coal tenure be completed and publicly vetted, to understand the hydrology of the affected watersheds (Cowie/Cougar Smith Creek, Tsable River, Wilfred Creek, Hindoo Creek, which all flow into Baynes Sound.

Write to, with copies to and

The Wonderful World of Web
Submissions to EcoNews

To buy ad space in the next EcoNews, or to submit your event to next month's Green Diary, please contact:

Guy Dauncey, Editor
395 Conway Road, Victoria, BC
Tel (250) 881-1304

Deadline for April issue March 24th


NewspaperPlease feel encouraged to repost.

EcoNews provides this electronic version of the newsletter without charge even though it costs around $1,100 CDN to produce each month.

If you can help by making a donation, whether $5 or $100, that would be most welcome. Please send it to: EcoNews, 395 Conway Rd, Victoria, B.C. V9E 2B9, Canada. Thanks ! (Not tax-deductible; if you want a receipt, please send a stamped addressed envelope).

Donations can also be sent via PayPal: